Introduction: Great Companies, Expensive Stocks, and the Art of Not Fooling Myself One thing I've learned from following the stock market is that Wall Street has an extraordinary ability to make almost anything sound like an investment opportunity. A company grows revenue by 96%, and suddenly investors are convinced they've discovered the next great wealth-building machine. Another company returns billions of dollars to shareholders, and dividend investors begin calculating how comfortably they could retire. A struggling business finally shows signs of improvement, and before the ink on its earnings report is dry, someone is already declaring the beginning of a spectacular turnaround. I understand the excitement. I enjoy finding businesses that are doing something remarkable. There's something satisfying about discovering a company whose operating results are genuinely improving while the broader market hasn't fully appreciated what's happening. But I've also le...
By the time Wall Street decides a company is hopeless, I usually start paying closer attention. But with Centene, the stock has already staged a spectacular recovery. Now I want to know whether the improving numbers justify another leg higher—or whether the bargain hunters are arriving after the bargain has left the building. Wall Street Has a Wonderful Habit of Panicking First and Reading the Earnings Report Later There are few things I enjoy more about the stock market than watching investors collectively decide a company is doomed, only to discover several months later that the business apparently forgot to cooperate with the apocalypse. It's one of Wall Street's more endearing personality disorders. A company runs into trouble, analysts lower their expectations, institutional investors start rearranging their portfolios, and suddenly everyone becomes a world-renowned expert on why the business model is permanently broken. The stock gets hammered, the financial media starts ...